FW:How does your dog food rate? Easy scoring guidelines.

[Edwpang]

I found the following link very useful:
http://largedog.meetup.com/boards/view/viewthread?thread=2914614

[sc.trojans]

I think all of the criteria outlined in this is great and good guidance for people.  But I am not sure what the basis for the point allocation is and presume it is the subjective view of the poster....

As a result, the final results are a bit baffling based on what I know about the quality of ingredients and production of the food.  That Eukanuba only gets a "C" and Nutro receives a good grade is suspect.

I do agree that somehow the results show Nature's Variety Raw Instincts as the top dry kibble - this is true.

[Moni]

Fredalina must be proud.    She is a friend off another list(GDR) that actually devised this system.  She did it for newbies looking into how to grade a food's quality compared to other's in a general way.  I find it amazing that it is now plastered all over the world wide web.  WTG Fred!

[AltDeutsche]

I have seen this before and love it!
Joker is on Royal Canin Large breed adult... I don't think we can get anything better around here.

I think too we need to take in consideration our breeds. Some need more protein and others need less. Definitely my Yorkie doesn't need what my Dane needs.