"the girls" used to eat Innova large breed (adult, 25 percent protein/$49 per 33lb bag) and did pretty well. Sera was the only one that still had ichy, licking problems. We decided to switch to Innova EVO red meat/large bite, grain-free(protein is 43 percent and $58 per 28lb bag) Suppose to be the closest to raw diet as a kibble can be. This has definately helped with the itching and licking, however, Mika has been chunking out on her backend/hips. I would like them to be on the same food, but I'm realizing that this will not happen. Mika will need to have less protein to get back and maintain her sleek figure. Shasta (110lbs) has chunked out since we got her. she gets the same amount of food as Sera(90lbs), but gains or maintains her "heftness". Shasta isn't as sensitive, so probably will also go back to a less protein diet. Love the Innova brand for my girls, but the recipe depends on each individual dog.